At Janakpuri District Centre, a developer claimed it had sold the space, the plaintiffs leased it to a bank, and the Delhi Development Authority’s complete building plan showed a public corridor. A Delhi court rejected the bid to keep the authorities from acting.

At T.C. Jaina Tower I, an ATM had a unit number, a registered bank lease and municipal tax records. What it lacked was approval to occupy the space. On 27 October 2025, a civil court at Tis Hazari found that unit G‑14A(III), on the ground floor of Plot 3 in Janakpuri District Centre, was an unauthorized encroachment on a public corridor. Usha and Rakesh Jain had asked the court to permanently restrain the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) from sealing or demolishing the premises. They lost. Civil judgment, Suit No. 11857/2016, paragraphs 1–8, 26, 34 and 41–45
The developer called it a sale. Where was the consent?
The plaintiffs said they bought the space from Jaina Properties Pvt. Ltd. for ₹10 lakh and subsequently leased it to Kotak Mahindra Bank, which used it for an ATM. Jaina Properties told the court it had sold and transferred the space and claimed the dispute was therefore no longer its concern. The developer then stopped contesting the suit. The court found that the document the plaintiffs relied on to claim ownership was a licence deed. It also found that the DDA’s written consent, required by its perpetual lease with the developer for such a transfer, was absent. Judgment, paragraphs 1–4, 17–18 and 34.1
That is why I call this a scam on the people who were meant to use that corridor. The developer claimed a sale, the plaintiffs put the space to commercial use, and the court found that the unit had never been sanctioned. There is a limit to what the judgment establishes about intent. When DDA accused the plaintiffs of suppressing material facts, the judge found no evidence of deliberate falsehood or bad-faith concealment by them and decided that issue in their favour. Jaina Properties still has a straightforward question to answer. On what authority did it treat a public corridor as space it could hand over? Judgment, paragraphs 17, 26, 31–34.1 and 40
Two plans, one date, and a shop that appeared on only one
Both plans bore the date 26 October 1999. The plaintiffs’ version showed a shop measuring 3.15 by 3.15 metres at the disputed location. DDA produced the complete plan, which showed no designated shop there. The judge said the plaintiffs had failed to explain the discrepancy and rejected their partial plan as unreliable. Their own witness acknowledged in cross-examination that neither the licence deed nor their plan provided for an ATM and that no DDA approval had been obtained to construct one. Judgment, paragraphs 20 and 27–34
A bank lease can show who occupied a space. A tax assessment can show that the municipality assessed it. The judge accepted these records as evidence of possession, then looked to the approved plan for evidence that the unit could lawfully exist there. The commercial paperwork accumulated around a unit the approving authority had never sanctioned. Judgment, paragraphs 25–34.1
DDA knew about the ATM issue years before the judgment
In July 2009, DDA told the Central Information Commission (CIC) that the builder had obtained no permission for an ATM in space earmarked for a fire control room. The Commission directed DDA to treat the information request as a complaint and act in accordance with the law. In August 2024, when the Commission revisited that direction, it recorded that it had gone unfulfilled, called DDA’s later reply evasive and directed that officials be asked to explain themselves. A separate DDA show-cause notice from February 2016, addressed to Jaina Properties about Plot 3, had listed the Kotak ATM among the alleged ground-floor alterations. August 2024 CIC order, pp. 2–4, reproducing the July 2009 direction
In July 2026, the Commission took up another RTI appeal, this one specifically about G‑14A(III). DDA’s Building Section had supplied an incomplete reply, failed to follow its own appellate authority’s direction, and missed the Commission hearing. The Commission called for written explanations from three DDA officers, covering Building, Legal and RTI coordination. Fifteen years after the first Commission direction, an evasive answer had already earned a rebuke. Two years later, a request for plans and litigation records was still producing incomplete answers. August 2024 CIC order, pp. 2–4 · July 2026 CIC order, pp. 5–6
The court lifted the stay. DDA should show what it did next.
The October 2025 judgment lifted the interim injunction and the stay on DDA’s 8 February 2011 show-cause notice. The court required DDA to follow due process in any enforcement. More than a year later, the documents reviewed for this post leave open what happened at the site and whether a later court order affected enforcement. Judgment, paragraphs 34.6 and 41–45
DDA should be able to give the public three dates. When did it inspect G‑14A(III) after the ruling? When did it take its next formal step? And if a later order stopped that step, when did the court issue it? If there has been no formal action, DDA should identify who has the file and explain the delay. Jaina Properties had an answer when it came to handing over the space. The public deserves an answer about getting its corridor back.