How the G-3 Dispute at Jaina Tower I Went from Civil Court to Arbitration

Jaina Properties went to civil court seeking to recover possession of G-3, a ground-floor commercial unit at T.C. Jaina Tower I in Janakpuri. The occupant, Satinder Pal Singh, invoked the arbitration clause in his licence agreement. After a Dwarka court rejected Jaina’s appeal, Jaina itself invoked arbitration. On 8 September 2026, the Delhi High Court appointed a sole arbitrator. Dwarka appellate judgment · Delhi High Court appointment order

Editorial illustration of two folders on a hearing-room table.
Editorial illustration for the G-3 arbitration case.

A ground-rent demand led to a civil suit

The dispute arose under a licence agreement dated 16 February 2000. According to the appellate judgment, Jaina alleged repeated defaults in ground rent and enhanced ground rent. It issued a show-cause notice on 13 January 2025 and a termination notice on 31 January 2025. Jaina then filed a civil suit seeking orders requiring Singh to vacate, along with damages. Dwarka appellate judgment, paragraphs 2 and 9

The agreement pointed to arbitration

At his first appearance, Singh applied under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, relying on Clause 41, which called for arbitration of disputes connected with the agreement or the parties’ relationship. Jaina relied on Clause 44, which named the Delhi courts, and argued that a dispute over possession could be heard in civil court despite the arbitration clause. Dwarka appellate judgment, paragraphs 3–6 and 10–13

On 17 January 2026, the trial court allowed Singh’s application and returned Jaina’s plaint. On 19 May 2026, the Dwarka appellate court dismissed Jaina’s appeal. It read Clause 44 as choosing Delhi as the place for court proceedings where appropriate, while giving effect to the arbitration clause. The ruling determined how the dispute would proceed. The alleged arrears and Jaina’s entitlement to possession remained open. Dwarka appellate judgment, RCA DJ 21/2026

Jaina then asked the High Court to appoint an arbitrator

Jaina issued a notice invoking arbitration on 22 June 2026. Singh declined to agree to Jaina’s proposed arbitrators without disputing the existence of the arbitration agreement. Jaina applied to the Delhi High Court under Section 11, and on 8 September 2026 the court appointed advocate Kamal Katyan as sole arbitrator under the rules of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre. The court left the parties’ claims, counterclaims, and preliminary objections for the arbitrator to decide. Delhi High Court order, paragraphs 4–9

For other occupants, G-3 shows why it’s worth reading the dispute clauses together. Here, the same licence named the Delhi courts and called for arbitration. Singh raised the arbitration clause at his first appearance, and that changed where Jaina pursued its claim. Dwarka appellate judgment

Public-record update, 13 November 2026. The latest published order located for this article is the High Court’s 8 September appointment order. No later public ruling or arbitral award was located. Delhi High Court appointment order

Scroll to Top